COMMENTS POLICY

Bars-N-Stripes is not responsible for any comments made by contributors in the Comments pages. However Bars-N-Stripes will exercise its right to moderate and edit comments which are deemed to be offensive or unsuited to the subject matter of this site.

Comments deemed to be spam or questionable spam will be deleted. Including a link to relevant content is permitted, but comments should be relevant to the post topic.
Comments including profanity will be deleted.
Comments containing language or concepts that could be deemed offensive will be deleted.
The owner of this blog reserves the right to edit or delete any comments submitted to this blog without notice. This comment policy is subject to change at any time.

Search This Blog

Showing posts with label U.S. Constitution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label U.S. Constitution. Show all posts

Monday, September 7, 2015

DOC Tidbits


THIS BLOG WAS WRITTEN IN NOVEMBER, 2014.
             Seems like every time you turn the news on, DOC is a lead story. This week, Virginia’s death row inmates have a suit pending (at the U.S 4th circuit sitting in Richmond) alleging their treatment is “cruel and unusual” in violation of the US Constitution. Now, hearing the term “cruel and unusual” you would think the case (already lost at trial level by DOC) would involve their death sentences. Nope. It seems, in its arbitrary way, DOC was faced with a lawsuit by one death row inmate over access to visits and other privileges. After losing that suit, DOC granted that one inmate the privileges sued for. But then, inexplicably, DOC denied those privileges to other death row inmates leading to this lawsuit.
            “We don’t comment on pending litigation,” said DOC spokesman Larry Traylor. Perhaps, you should. Perhaps it’s time you explain to Virginia’s taxpayers the millions spent each year defending inmate lawsuits DOC continues to lose. Perhaps the DOC Director should be called to account for the money wasted, the lives lost, and the complete ineptitude and mismanagement he oversees. Nah. That would leave me less to write about.
            Not to be outdone, a judge in Chesterfield County released a convicted child-sex abuser (a minister convicted of having improper sexual contact with two minor female family members) on home incarceration pending sentencing in January. He’s facing 99 years yet the judge let him go home with an ankle monitor. I wonder how many young, black kids using drugs get post-conviction release while awaiting sentencing. How about guilty-plea embezzling lawyers? It’s unheard of, yet this judge decided it was appropriate in this case. Makes you wonder.
            Finally, as I write this 3 more men here with serious medical problems are being ignored. What is the response from each of their families? Call the ACLU in Richmond (the Fluvanna women’s suit against DOC for negligent medical care is set for December 5th) and hire counsel.
            And so it goes with DOC and the criminal justice system.
 

Thursday, September 4, 2014

Ferguson

I was still learning my way around the jail, still new to “life” behind bars when I met Ferguson. He was a clean-cut deputy, white, polite, mid-thirties. He spoke to me when he’d come through the pod. He treated me with respect. He treated me the way I was used to being treated…

There was a young black kid in the pod with me. He was always angry and he was, how do I say it, not right in the head. His eyes darted; he spoke in fragments, his hair was a jumbled mess, which matched his clothing and his personal hygiene. I learned on day 1 in the pod to stay clear of this kid.

So one morning this kid goes up to the booth and knocks on the Plexiglas. “I gotta go to court” he stammers and spits out. “You aren’t even on the list,” the deputy retorts in a mocking tone. “I … gotta … go … to … fuckin … court … you motherfuc … !” The kid is swearing and yelling and banging on the Plexiglas booth. “Step back from the booth!” Now the deputy is raising his voice.

This goes on for ten minutes or so and I am transfixed by the idiocy of it all. I’ve never seen anything like this. The kid has run back and forth to his cell a half dozen times only to come back to the booth, hurl profanity at the Plexiglas, paper in hand, demanding to be taken to court. And the booth officer continues to mock and berate him each time, goading him to “come through the glass.” Finally, the pod door opens and in steps Ferguson. He seeks to present a calm presence, but a presence of authority. With his hand raised as a stop sign he politely, but forcefully says, “Son, step away from the booth and go to your cell. You are not going to court.” The kid stops banging on the glass. He turns to the officer and in slow, steady steps approaches him. I notice he has a Styrofoam cup in his hand. I notice it the same time Ferguson does, just as the cup is being thrown at the officer. I look and I watch and I see …

“He threw shit on Ferguson!” The pod erupts. The kid had defecated in the Styrofoam cup and tossed it on the officer. And Ferguson’s hand is now dropped; his authority vanishing before my eyes. “Ferguson is covered in shit!” The chant begins. The pod doors fly open and four beefy, camouflaged clad officers rush in. Three wrestle and throw the kid to the floor; the fourth tries to help Ferguson. I watch it all in amazement. And I wonder, how do you recover after you’ve been covered in excrement?

I thought about all that as I watched another unarmed black kid get killed by a white cop and then hoodlums turn legitimate protests into an excuse to loot. Ferguson, Missouri (this time) is covered in shit. Will we ever learn?

“By vigorously defending the rights of individuals, we keep in check the excesses of the government which, if allowed to grow unbridled, would consume us all.”

These are the words of a conservative Republican, a former New Jersey Assemblyman and lawyer, John W. Hartmann. “Unbridled government.” We live in a post 9/11 America where the police are now given free reign, by the Pentagon, MRAPs (armored personnel carriers). We saw this week police arrest reporters and Baptist preachers for doing nothing more than observing the cluster f --- that has been the police response to the killing of an unarmed black young man at their hands.

Hey folks, this is still America. This “power by government gun” was what the founding fathers were so adamant about challenging in the 1760s through the Revolution. And yet, we have become a nation that buys the lie that the police and the government are working to keep us safe and secure. “Surrendering liberty in the name of security and safety gives you neither.”  Old Ben Franklin, where are you?

Black and white. Here are simple facts – blacks and whites commit crimes generally in equal rates yet four out of five arrests are of blacks. Last year, four hundred police shootings – like the one in Ferguson – took place against black teen males; less than fifty involved white teens. We talk – and by “we” I mean people who look like me – white and affluent – about America being a “color blind” society. I call “bullshit.” Electing a black man President doesn’t get America over its racial animus. It is time for white America to honestly assess race. “All men are created equal; they are endowed by their creator …” Those words are a universal truth, not applicable only to one color, one creed.

Glenn Loury, author of The Anatomy of Racial Inequality posed the following:
“Can we imagine a large majority of young white men being rounded up for minor drug offenses, placed under the control of the criminal justice system, labeled felons, and subjected to a lifetime of discrimination, scorn, and exclusion? No, we cannot. If such a thing occurred it would make us wonder, ‘what is wrong with us?’”

What, indeed.

A story. My older son was junior in high school. He was an honor student, on the school’s “Battle of the Brains” team. The high school was in a “drug free” zone, which, I later learned gave the local police power to run drug dogs through anytime the police deemed it “necessary.” Did I mention that out kids attended a majority black school?

So this day, the dogs come through and sit by my son while he’s taking a test. He is led out of the room and he and his book bag are searched. He is then escorted out to his car, which is also searched. No drugs; no nothing. He tells me what happened and I explode – not at him but at an arrogant sheriff who thinks he can run in to a school, violate the U.S. constitution and search minors without parental consent.

The next day, my wife and I meet with the school superintendent. I’m ready to sue the bastards. “You will not search nor interview my son, nor any other minor for alleged criminal activity without the express consent of the parents.”

She understood, and she agreed. But then she said this: “Most parents don’t say a word. Most think the police can do what they want.” They can’t. Every day you need to remind yourself, this isn’t a police state; this is America. And if we’re going to get the old lump in the throat and talk about what a “blessed” country this is, it’s high time we require government to live up to its founding ideals.

The police in Ferguson can pull out MRAPs, they can set off tear gas, they can arrest reporters, but they can’t explain why an unarmed black teen with his hands up is dead; and, they can’t explain why the shooter is on paid administrative leave.

Black and white. How many more Fergusons must there be? How many more black teens have to be gunned down before white families say “that could be our son?” How many more MRAPs need to be let loose in small towns across this country before we say enough?

About two weeks after the Styrofoam cup incident I saw Ferguson. He’d been reassigned from the pods to the attorney visiting area. He wasn’t the same. He couldn’t figure out why the kid lashed out at him. I saw that same look with the white cops the other night demanding that the crowds disperse in Ferguson. Their guns drawn, fear and apprehension in their faces, they couldn’t understand why so many black people walked by, hands in the air, shouting “don’t shoot.”

It’s time we figured it out; it’s time for an end to hoodlums running amok because we are divided into white America and black America, and the militarization of local police. It’s time to stop seeing America in black and white.


Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Dear Anonymous

I received a print copy of your 10/20 response to a recent blog about a “typical” week here.  I’ve been busy teaching my own class (yes, they’ve given me some independence to get guys ready for the GED!) and thinking about the election, but your comments deserve a response.

First, I appreciate you reading my blog.  When I started it two and a half years ago, my goal was to connect – in some way – with the outside world.  Too often, prison – with its security apparatus and “scarlet letter” understanding that “bad people are behind the fence” – isolates and alienates those incarcerated.  Simply put, we forget what its like out there.  Twenty-four seven we are watched and cared for.  We lose connection with decision making and those things that should matter in your daily life.
Compounding that, most people locked up come from less than desirable lives.  Drug and alcohol abuse, broken homes, poverty, lack of education, lack of stable employment, the list of social ills that most of the incarcerated have lived through is enough to teach graduate level sociology.  And I don’t say that to make excuses for people’s decisions. But, until we as a nation have the collective will to – as the words of the U.S. Constitution so eloquently state it, “provide for the general welfare” – tackle the manifest despair in poor, broken families, we will fail as a nation.  That’s not a Republican or Democrat idea.  If anything, it’s part of my faith journey.  “Am I my brother’s keeper?”  After four and a half years in here, the answer is a heartfelt “yes”.

As for your boyfriend not “sharing” the world in here, I understand that and I hope you do to.  I’ve noted and told self described “tough guys” in here that they aren’t so tough.  Many men refuse to admit they’re scared, or lonely, or just tired and ready to quit.  In here, that is a sign of weakness.  And too often weakness will get you in trouble.  I have something that counters the toughest.  From the day I was arrested inmates knew I’ been a lawyer, knew I had multiple degrees.  Knowledge, education trumps all the rest.  They fear that their ignorance will be exposed.
Your boyfriend keeps you from the “real” prison because, frankly, it’s not pretty.  For most, it is nothing but a waste of time and money.  And sometimes inmates behave in ways they know are wrong.  Getting by, getting along, sometimes is the best approach.

James Lee Burke is one of my favorite American authors.  He understands broken men better than many.  In one novel his protagonist said “the bravest and most loyal and loving people in the world seldom have heroic physical characteristics or the aura of saints.”
I love those words.  They remind me that you can be decent even in a depressed place like this, and love, friendship and loyalty can survive even prison.  I know that in my own life.  I am blessed to have a wonderful group of friends “outside” who have loved and upheld me in the worst of days.

As for your generous comments about my ex, I have a certain sad ambivalence about my divorce.  At some point in this past four and a half years, I had my “Lt. Dan” moment.  I yelled at God and demanded to know why, why was my punishment worse than my sin?  And it hit me.  God is sovereign.  He knows more than I ever will.  And if I truly have faith I have to accept the divorce, the rejection, the loss, as part of His plan to make me to be what He sees.
I hurt, I ache over the loss.  Fact is, I will always love her.  But, it’s OK.  In this – as in every part of this journey I realize I’m not alone and there are amazing lessons – and stories – for me.

Keep reading.  Keep the faith.  And, thanks for your comments.

Sunday, December 19, 2010

Legally Speaking

I spend hours each week in the prison law library, every Monday to Thursday evening, 6:30 to 8:30 pm; writing, typing, researching the law to help other inmates with a variety of legal issues. From divorce to name changes to complicated legal arguments on constitutional law involving evidence, convictions, and prisoner rights, I run a solo underground law practice. I am the prison’s legal aid clinic. I try not to say “no” to anyone posing a legal question. I’ll show any man at least the courtesy and respect to hear them tell of their legal concerns.



As I’ve written before, the law library here doesn’t amount to much. Outdated books line the shelves (the set of Virginia Codes hasn’t been updated since 1998). There is only one research computer, with CD case and statue information, that is only updated semi-annually. Four antiquated “Selectric” typewriters are spread around the room, a mere 10 ft by 10 ft block room that has seating for a maximum of five inmates.


In truth, the library fails to comply with the minimum required by the United States Constitution for inmate access to the courts.


Many inmates, already uneducated, abandoned and discouraged by their circumstances, bemoan the law. They have no confidence in the American judicial system, a system that far too often is made up of incompetent attorneys and judges, and a prosecution bias to get revenge rather than find justice.


For me, however, the challenge of taking on “the bastards” under these conditions keeps me going night in and night out. I have a few “cards up my sleeve” that keep me going.


First, to almost every man here, I am “lawyer Larry”. Guys know I bust my butt to help them. Their confidence in me keeps me going.


Second, my cousin is an amazing researcher. Any case I need, any statute, study or legal article I can think of gets mailed in to me. Thanks to her and her husband I have a more update law library in my footlocker than the prison provides.


Third, I know how to type. Even on the old Selectrics. I can kick out almost 70 words a minute.


Fourth, they can throw me in prison, but they can’t take away all I learned as an undergraduate, in law school and practicing law and working in business. I know what cases say, I know what statutes mean.


And finally, I give a damn. Too often, guys get short-changed by both court appointed and hired lawyers who are too busy, too lazy, or too stupid to bother to properly prepare their cases for trial. They quickly agree to plea deals without adequately investigating the case or the ramifications of the plea.


With all that, I’m kept busy by the law. Here’s a legal primer on issues every inmate brings up.


I. Conditional Pardons. The Governor has the power to alter any criminal sentence as he sees fit. Inmates may apply every two years if turned down. The request goes through the office of the Secretary of the Commonwealth. You don’t have to be innocent to get a pardon. The Governor can convert your prison term to supervised probation if he wants.


II. Habeas Corpus. Under the Sixth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, a defendant has a right to “effective assistance of counsel”. Inmates file Petitions for Writs of “Hab” to get their convictions set aside and force the state to retry them.


It’s a difficult process. There are significant time limitations that trap many unsophisticated inmates. The law also presumes (1) that your attorney was effective [there are cases where lawyers were drunk or asleep during the trial and the courts held counsel was effective]; and (2) that the underlying trial, conviction and sentence were properly entered.


It’s a difficult process. Most lawyers don’t understand it, yet each day inmates representing themselves do legal battle with all the power the Virginia Attorney General’s office can muster. That any inmate can succeed under these conditions is amazing. That so many do is remarkable.


III. §1983 claims. Inmates are entitled to certain basic rights. The Constitution applies even in prison. Bad health care, corrupt officers, religious discrimination, censorship, all those issues are addressed by inmate suits under federal law. As I’ve previously written, this year DOC has taken a beating in Federal Court on a number of issues.


The bureaucracy of DOC is astounding. They pick fights and push issues that bear little rational relationship to their stated purpose, namely to house and rehabilitate incarcerated prisoners.


You would think a criminal justice institution would understand and properly apply the law. Sadly, that is not the case. §1983 suits continue to flourish and taxpayers continue to spend millions a year in legal fees and expenses to defend DOC in inmate suits seeking Constitutional protection.


Inmates file hundreds, even thousands of grievances, writs for legal redress, even crazy suits (one sought to have his social security number removed and be declared an unincorporated person; “they can’t imprison an unincorporated person”) in an attempt to either “get justice” or “stick it to the man”.


Legally speaking, men desperate for justice, men who feel the system isn’t fair, will try anything to be heard. So much money being wasted because the system is broken and corrupt; so much work for a lawyer.