Each morning, Monday through Friday at 7:15, the men of
building 3B trudge across the compound to sit in a large circle in the
visitation room. There, under the
direction of “specially trained” staff and officers, these 96 men engage in the
daily ritual of preparing for release. They
are all within four to eight months of their release date and live together and
participate in group programs under the auspices of Governor Bob McDonnell’s “Offender
Re-entry Initiative” (he’ll regularly promote his “initiative” in the
press). And what do these men do to
prepare for “the real world”? They play “Simon
Says”.
Yes, Virginia, your Governor’s re-entry plan has inmates
within months of release playing Simon Says.
Not to be outdone, they also play “red light, green light” and have
volunteers stand up and give “testimonials” about how “today I decided not to
steal my neighbor’s radio”. This is
Governor McDonnell’s answer to the billion dollar embarrassment that is
Virginia DOC. And ironically, the officers and teachers will tell you it’s the same
failed program 20 year employees have seen three times before. Oh, it may have a new name and different bells
and whistles, but it’s the same failed concept that every Governor, every “tough
on crime” politician has supported to break Virginia’s high incarceration rate,
stagnant recidivism level and increasingly cost prohibitive system, while
continuing to justify no early release incentives for the vast majority of
incarcerated offenders. Bob McDonnell, I have concluded, is just another in a
long line of snake oil salesmen who lack either the guts or the intellect to
speak the truth and do what needs to be done with Virginia’s bloated, failed
prison system.
I’m not the brightest guy in the world (my status as a
member of Virginia’s inmate population confirms that) but just one day in
prison was enough to convince me society’s approach to corrections was
misdirected and doomed to failure. It
doesn’t take a genius to realize the following:
1) The
abolishment of parole has done nothing to either decrease the cost of incarcerating
or the rate of recidivism amongst released offenders. Instead it has created the largest department
bureaucracy in Virginia government (13,000 DOC employees) and seen the inmate
population swell from 9,600 (in 1995) to almost 40,000 (year-end 2010), a 400%
increase in less than 15 years with one of every eight state budget dollars now
going to corrections.
2) The
vast majority of inmates currently languishing in Virginia’s prisons are either
nonviolent offenders or, due to the number of years held, have had their
security levels reduced to low custody. The
majority of Virginia’s prisons are low to medium security facilities with
dorm-style housing and a majority of the officer corps being females.
You want a meaningful re-entry initiative? Focus – and resources – should be directed as
follows:
1) Real
drug and alcohol treatment. A significant number of the incarcerated suffer
from drug and alcohol abuse issues. DOC
treatment plans call for those inmates to attend treatment, however, those
programs are group meetings, short duration (ten to fifteen weeks) that use a
cookie-cutter “here are the stats” approach.
Meaningful treatment is needed, not boring, earn your certificate
classes.
2) Job/life
skills training. I am in the minority in here for a number of reasons but one
significant reason is I actually held a real job requiring regular hours. Prisons have all sorts of vocational programs
to teach a person how to be an electrician but there is nothing about paying
taxes, running a business, buying a house, signing a lease, keeping a checking
account. The vast majority of inmates
committed crimes because they were incapable of successfully navigating day to
day life.
3) Education. The single most important determining factor
in recidivism is a college education, yet funding for prison college programs
has been repeatedly cut. The vast
majority of inmates in Virginia’s prisons lack basic skills and don’t even have
their high school diplomas. An un or
under-educated offender is the primary driving force behind recidivism.
4) Meaningful
Mental Health treatment. A significant
number of offenders suffer from mental health disorders. At this compound alone at least 200 of the
1200 incarcerated are on some sort of psychological meds. Depression, anxiety, guilt, collapse of
relationships, all flow freely around the compound like an open sewage
ditch. Yet, psychological counseling is
a triage system. Suicidal? Drop a note, go to the hole, get
antidepressants and a visit with the psychologist. There is no individual counseling. And the
guys on Prozac and all the rest? Once a
quarter they participate in a “video conference” with the department
psychiatrist. He asks three
questions: 1. Any problems? 2.
Taking your meds? 3. Any side effects? Meds are used to temper behavior, but the
underlying causes are left untreated.
Governor McDonnell will tell anyone what a giant step
forward his re-entry program is for corrections. It isn’t.
He is either a bold-faced liar or living in wonderland. His re-entry program is no different than all
the programs run in prison since parole was abolished which have failed
miserably.
That much of the prison reform movement is not being driven
by conservatives should come as no surprise.
The cost benefit analysis of incarceration proves what one day behind
bars teaches. Prisons fail.
In a few short weeks the Virginia General Assembly will meet
to consider the Commonwealth’s biannual budget.
No matter how much the politicians tell you Virginia has weathered the
recession, be skeptical. Virginia has a
tremendous IOU in its state retirement plan.
State employees have again been denied raises. Governor McDonnell could show leadership,
real leadership, and introduce legislation to restore parole or, at the very
least, restructure sentences so that offenders could earn significantly more
good time. A real re-entry program could
be created. An offender like me could be
released and brought back in to continue the work I do.
The cost to house an inmate in Virginia at even a low level
is $25,000 per year. That’s $68.50 per
day. The cost to monitor that same
inmate through “community corrections” (i.e. probation) is $8.00 per day. Under the current system 60% of the incarcerated
will recommit within three years of release.
Prison, simply put, is a sinking hole of quick sand.
I have repeatedly urged the Governor in this blog to put his
faith and intellect into action and build a real prison reform agenda. The time for demagoguery and false promises
is over. Virginia needs real prison
reform. Simon says “now”.